Top 5 Scariest TFTDS Episodes Ever

[trevor]

Since the first time I watched the opening credits on wgn years ago, Tales from The Darkside fascinated me. But I would be lying if I said my expectations weren't a bit lowered with some(if not most) episodes. Simply put; most episodes weren't so much scary as they were comedically ironic.

Of course, fear is subjective. What frightens me may not you and vice-versa. But I've seen every TFTDS episode and I'm willing to state that the following list moves out of the realm of opinion and into stated fact. This is the 5 scariest Tales From The Darkside episodes ever produced:

Trick Or Treat (pilot)
In The Closet (s1ep8)
Halloween Candy (s2ep5)
The Circus (s3ep1)
Family Reunion (s4ep16)

[ray64]

Solid list. Notice that you included both episodes that were directed by Tom Savini which would definitely make my top five cut. Nice job!

Also, Patricia Tallman = RAWR!

[J]

No list would be complete without "The Last Car"